Monday, December 3, 2012

Final Project Rough Draft


                When entering the world of pop culture, crazy, cult-like fans viciously supporting their favorite television show is an aspect one can hardly miss when examining media. Topping the list of devoted-base, Supernatural and Buffy the Vampire Slayer contain a fairly large number of not just fans, but devoted followers. These fans go beyond the rabid viewer, and delve deeper into the shows core, treating the show as a lifestyle, and not a form of occasional entertainment. However, these mythological and religious-based shows have not only attracted fans, but also hatred, being called blasphemous by various different religious communities.  However, these religious communities hardly differ from these devoted fan-bases including a parallel in devotion, a gathering of people with similar beliefs, and a center point of the gathering people that offers different interpretations of historical religious beliefs.  Therefore, with such similarities and a lack of a concrete definition of religion, are Buffy and Supernatural not, in their own right, a religion?

                Of course, before one can determine what constitutes as religion, one must understand the definition of religion.  Then again, is there a definition of religion? The answer is yes, there are many different definitions of religion that vary amongst people, cultures, and acknowledged religions.  One of the biggest issues, as Steve Bruce, a professor at the University of Aberdeen majoring in sociology, points out, religion is often defined by a person by the religious, moral beliefs of the individual.  For instance, if a person defining religion is Christian, than to be a religion, one must believe in one god. Christopher Peet, a professor at University of Alberta believes the theories used to define religion all have faults, therefore, one cannot say something is not a religion because the counter-views do not hold strong enough evidence.  Peet also continues on the theory that, to many people, something cannot truly be defined as religion if it is not acknowledged by the public and government as such. It becomes obvious when attempting to create a definition of religion that religion is a difficult word to define. With a subject so sensitive as religion, it will likely never be truly defined.  Therefore, to say a T.V. show center around religious ideas that offer different interpretations of these religious values is not a religion is simply wrong, seeing as religion not only lacks a concrete definition, but also because religion is a word used to describe a group of people who believe in similar ideas regarding the afterlife or purpose of life, and this description describes the majority of Supernatural and Buffy fans.

               

3 comments:

  1. This is really good start and I think you doing a great job for the beginning of your essay. You presented your thesis, which I might say is very interesting, and started providing an argument to prove your thesis. I also like the way you approached this. Religion is a touchy subject for the majority of the public and you approached it with ease while conveying your point as well. I really can't wait to see what you do with this essay!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hmm. I like how you have edged your focus a bit toward the meaning of religion, both as what it is and how it applies to your topic. A slant this could also lead to is how certian religions percieve the shows that you are researching (i.e. The catholic church probaly isn't a big fan of vampires or their slayers! :)) Your points are sharp and focused. The thesis is well stated. Keep it up!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey you! :)

    I think you have an interesting connection in your research - buffy the vampire slayer and religion? I haven't thought about this before, but it seems that you have a point! You focus a lot on the definition of religion, and I fully understand why, as it is important to understand that concept in order to accept your argument. I'm interested to see where this research takes you, it is not a topic I have heard or read about before. The comparison of buffy fans and haters build a strong similarity to recognized religion. Go on!

    ReplyDelete